Felix Rambles

Another step to taking back control

Freedom and responsibility in software

24 June 2019 — Felix Ple┼čoianu

In today's news, the world of free software discovers that freedom entails responsibility, and reacts in typical male fashion: by panicking.

Which reminds me that I spent years exploring the concept of freedom in my stories, and no matter how I looked at it, one conclusion imposed itself every time: there is no freedom without belonging. If you don't belong anywhere, that doesn't make you free, but adrift. Conversely, if you belong where you are, are you really a prisoner? It's not like you'd leave even if the door was wide open.

This, by the way, is why I find the Stockholm Syndrome a dubious notion at best. It's predicated on a gung-ho conception of freedom that only flies in Hollywood movies. And we all know what happens every time a certain world superpower tries to force this brand of "freedom" on other, older countries.

Freedom, you see, is a political concept by definition. Yet for the longest time free software fanatics tried to pretend their creations were these idealized, abstract shapes adorning marble halls of intellectual purity. Anyone can use the software for any purpose, and we're not liable for anything!

You'd expect that kind of attitude from the gun-toting libertarian who rebranded free software as open source. But no, freedom zero is right there at the top of the General Public License as originally published in 1984. Oh wait, it was written by a lawyer. Minimizing liability is what they do for a living.

How appealing to cocky young programmers who were taught that cynicism was a sign of intelligence. And they bought it wholesale, because it spared them from having to show empathy. Empathy hurts, you know. Lots of bad stuff happening these days. Lots of bad people happening, too.

Well, now they're using all that "neutral", "unbiased" software we filled the world with to spread hate, perpetuate injustice or snatch innocent victims. And we can't revoke all those licenses, pretty much by design. That, too, seemed like a good idea at the time.

Guess it's time to figure out something else then. Before the consequences catch up with us.

Tags: software, freedom, politics

Comments? Tweet